I recently played through Mass Effect for the Xbox 360, and then replayed it, and then replayed it again because there are so many paths you can take through it that it really can be a different experience each time. I love this game. After so many play-throughs, though, it occurred to me that I was getting a little too into this game, and I should move on to something else. This is proving harder than I expected.
I bought Knights of the Old Republic for ten bucks, figuring another highly-recommended Bioware title would do nicely. After playing for a couple hours, though, I can’t seem to get into it. The early, directionless search for Bastila bores me, as it has me talking to digital actors who don’t look very impressive. The overcrowded interfaces in the pause menus both bore and confuse me. The turn-based combat really bores me: The worst thing you can possibly do during combat is move, so it becomes a matter of actually doing as little as possible to survive.
Before this, I had tried playing Beyond Good and Evil for Gamecube, another game greatly celebrated for its story. I had a hard time getting into this one as well. In both games, the period of learning how to play seems far too long to keep me interested. Plus, I think I am spoiled by the stories and graphics of Xbox 360 games like Mass Effect, Bioshock, Splinter Cell: Double Agent, and Kane & Lynch.
It’s now dawning on me that I might have already played the best that contemporary gaming has to offer in terms of storytelling, which is kind of sad—both because I may have run out of stuff to enjoy and because even “the best of the best” has been imperfect to say the least. I don’t know how to look past my prejudices to enjoy older games the way others enjoyed them so much, though I wonder if there really is something that genuinely rubs me the wrong way about their design, as I did not have this problem at all with Psychonauts or Ico on PS2.
Just in case, though, I’d like to put this out before you all: Is there something I’m missing? Does KOTOR suddenly leap from mediocrity into awesomeness if I just stick with it a couple more hours? Are there other original Xbox games that better stand the test of time? Or does my disappointment sound all too familiar to you—do story games become a lot less appealing once their technology loses its novelty? And, even if that’s the case, are there other 360 games with underrated stories that I should be checking out? (I heard good things about Prey, but I am wary of a 360 game that is on sale used for ten bucks.)
Perhaps I just need to be patient until the deluge of promising releases between August and November this year (Star Wars: Force Unleashed, Splinter Cell: Conviction, Too Human, etc.), but I’m hoping that someone can suggest something else to me in the meantime.